Quantcast


Feb 10 2010

What's the BUZZ Tell Me What's Happening with Facebook vs Google Buzz?

google buzz, facebook, buzz vs facebook

Poor Google social media smart guys. They have sooooo much momentum and so much "buzz" around anything they launch and yet they really have not had a home run.  And it's not that they haven't tried, they have: case Orkut = sharable profile. Jaiku = Twitter wanna be, and most recently the service I can't even get the advocates for the service to really respond to: WAVE.

So now enter BUZZ. Ho hum. Are you surprised that it doesn't sync with Facebook yet? Are you really surprised by that?

FastCompany tries to make news out of the launch, but comes up short with this scoring.

1. Media Integration: Buzz wins simply because it's easier to connect than Facebook. Well, at least to Picassa and Flikr and Twitter. (I'd actually score this for Facebook, cause you can integrate almost every account.)

2. Interface: Facebook wins. (Ha ha, we'll get to Facebook's new interface violations in a bit.)

3. Fun Factor: Facebook wins. (Yeah, it's a social thing after all. FB has games, causes, pages… Buzz has… well, g-mail.)

Okay so what's so great about buzz?

Screen shot 2010 02 10 at 5.53.35 PM Whats the BUZZ Tell Me Whats Happening with Facebook vs Google Buzz?

1. It's from Google. (Okay I think we've established that the Google umbrella offers little in terms of will we use it, will people flock to the party if we build a new party room bolted on the side of gmail?

2. Nobody's on it yet. (Are we really ready to start building our social networks again, on another service? Well, are you?)

3. It's got the big "so what" tag on it. What does buzz actually do that is interesting, unique or more efficient?

It might really be more of a competitor to Tweetdeck and Seesmic as a megaphone for initiating your tweets, bleeps, pings, wall scrivings and giving you some Google love in the process. *Might be.*

So what's the resistance?

Or for me, what's the value of spending time putting together my profile and my connections on Buzz? At the moment I don't see it. And I AM an early adopter, but not necessarily an early evangelist.

The part of Google I discovered last night when the "See Buzz in your G-Mail Account" link was not doing anything was this.

Screen shot 2010 02 09 at 11.02.07 PM Whats the BUZZ Tell Me Whats Happening with Facebook vs Google Buzz?

They might not get my mindshare with Buzz, but they got my Blackberry coming and going. I could care less about Buzz, frankly. But I want the WAVE to work, I just can't find anyone else quite as passionate about the WAVE as I am. At least not in my limited WAVE-lets here in Austin, Texas.

Let's see if anyone uses WAVE at SXSWi this year. I'm pretty sure you won't hear a word about Buzz. And I'm pretty sure you will still hear too much about iPhone apps and APIs and Twitter-enabled apps.

I can't wait to see how this pans out. Buzz – meh. WAVE – bring it!

@jmacofearth
permalink: http://bit.ly/you-buzz

Interesting note: Since I use FriendFeed to integrate all of my social networks, I wonder if I can add my BUZZ to FF yet? Or how soon will a WordPress plug-in like Sociable add BUZZ as a new option? Let's see: Jan 10, 2010, 6:24 CST.

Tags: , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , ,


Aug 11 2009

FriendFeed and Facebook Sittin in a Tree: What Will Become of Us FFers?

Category: social mediajmacofearth @ 10:59 am

Picture 24

Okay, so it's a done deal. And my ambivalence comes with some measure of relief. It's no secret that FF has been failing to thrive.

Picture 53

But so many things about the granddaddy Facebook suck. And while FF is not perfect, and has made some missteps in the past, it forms the core of my social media STACK. Won't I be hoppin mad if @stop and company wreck FF by trying to "integrate it" into the FB morass? Well, yes, I will.

For now I will stay hopeful and ignorant of the motivation behind FB's move and be glad FF will continue to exist. Cause it wouldn't have been very good had it gone under either. So it's a mixed blessing. Perhaps I need to start looking at those personal aggregation plug-ins for WordPress. Or roll my own.

Until then, here's to the longevity of FF outside of the FB empire.

@jmacofearth
permalink: http://bit.ly/FB-FF

See also The Twitter Way, my current collection of writings on Twitter: usage, fun and failures.

Tags: , , , , , , , , , , , , ,


Aug 05 2009

What's Your Social Media STACK? Application Framework? Social Media Workflow?

We've all got one. Even if you don't think you have one, you have one. It may be really simple: 1. I use Facebook and I use Twitter & I email and txt. Or it could be complex involving more than 5 apps and platforms. However your STACK is of critical importance to getting YOUR version of social media done.

What I want to explore here is the evolving social media stack, and look at how I process a few tasks (URL filing and recall or bookmarking; tweeting interesting links) and a some of the pitfalls and problems I've encountered. I'd like nothing more than to get a thread going with people contributing their STACKS, but I'll stick with the focus on myself. Feel free to add your STACK in the comments.

The primary components of my social media engagement are blogs, linkedin, facebook and twitter. And here is how I break down my time spent on social media tasks.

  • 20% random browsing (using RSS or iGoogle as starting points for exploration to researching tech topics for my tech writing)
  • 30% my blogs (writing and optimizing uber.la and various other blogs I manage)
  • 10% twitter (meme hunting, networking, self-promotion, sharing social media knowledge, humor and links)
  • 10% facebook (social connections and meme hunting)
  • 25% business/tech blogs (reading, posting, commenting)
  • 5% linkedIN (making connections and hunting up more work) [I might need to bump this up a little.]

Here's how my top 3 are managed:

Picture 55

For the most part I use Tweetdeck and Friendfeed to populate my social media sites. I go to Twitter.com only to manage followers and friends. I do visit Facebook more often, even though I can see friends status updates in Tweetdeck. It's much easier to make posts and connections from the Facebook site.

I don't visit LinkedIN very often. But when I do I am either posting an article that I think will be of benefit to one of my groups or I am researching a company for consulting work or to find a colleague.

Here is how the Friendfeed system takes my inputs from various sources and aggregates them into one site and outputs them to multiple streams that I can use for different purposes.

Picture 12

In the early days [meaning a year ago] when I couldn't keep track of all my services I would use FF as my landing page to go find my Flickr account or to link to my YouTube account. I still do that from time to time, but I won't admit it.

So let's see the two different ways I post URLs to share.

The first method I use for URLs that are more temporary. Not necessarily a link I want to put into my filing system for retrieval, but of interest nonetheless. For these URLs I use the FriendFeed web widget:

Picture 24

When the link I want to share is more serious, more of a resource that I will want to go back to, I put it in my virtual filing cabinet using Delicious. Once the URL is in Delicious I can tag and categorize the link in many ways that make sense to me.

Picture 25

I might share one of these links to Twitter as well, but initially I have FriendFeed set to NOT post Delicious links to Twitter. In this way, my FriendFeed links go to Twitter automatically as intended. And my Delicious links DO post to my FriendFeed page (thus getting stored in my FriendFeed info stream) but they DO NOT post to my Twitter stream. There is such thing as OVERSHARING, and I have been tried a number of ways to cut down on my number of tweets and up the quality of the URLs I do post via Twitter.

Several pitfalls I fell into during my "early" learning learning phase was to allow too many other sites tweet my updates. A real stand out in the music discovery market is Blip.fm. I love Blip. And for a while I was playing TweeJay, my name for Twitter-DJay. When I would blip a song it would post to my twitter feed that I was listening to XYZ song. While this was fun, I started thinking about what "value" I wanted to provide to my tweeps. I did an assessment and what I found was that my tweetstream looked like this. [I need to do an updated assessment.]

my twitter makeup (based on 1002 tweets)

22% of my tweets at that time were BLIPs! Not exactly what I was trying to build as a reputation. So I turned off the Blips. I still use Blip, but today my TweeJay announcements stay on Blip.fm alone.

Another auto-feed I had a problem with was harder to root out. And here is where having a sense of your Social Media STACK is important. In the course of updating a few of my connections I had inadvertently enabled a daily Delicious Links update that tweeted a daily summary page of my Delicious links.

And here's the funny part. When I saw the first few Tweets I started trying to figure out WHERE the preference was that was creating the daily "Delicious Links for 8-2-09" tweets. First stop, Delicious. It seemed reasonable that Delicious would be putting up the "Delicious Links" tweet. But I could not find an auto-tweet setting anywhere.

Picture 40

Next step Friendfeed, cause that's what FF does, is aggregates stuff and re-outputs it where you want it. But again I could not find anything directly linking Delicious and Twitter.

Picture 26

UPDATE 8-5-09: Delicious added a Post to Tweet feature today so now you can add that to your blueprint planning as well:

Picture 68

[I turned off my Delicious to FF to Twitter updates at this time and have not turned them back on.] And writing this I can't remember where the preference was found. I think it might have been Disqus. [Going off to check for the Delicious to Twitter update preference.]

Picture 41

Nope, Disqus was clear. And then I remembered: I had been telling someone last week how great some of the Feedburner features were and how bad some of the features were. Here's the offending pref on my uber.la Feedburner account that was causing the trouble. Something called Link Splicer. [Bad title, bad idea!]

Picture 42

So when you sum it all up, you NEED to understand your Social Media STACK. Breaks in the pipes, additive tweets and posts, organizing and maintaining your social media information flow is critical to your success. This does not mean it has to be overly complex. In fact, my goal is always to simplify my structure over time and make adjustments based on goals and changing application availability and features.

Picture 51

And even then there are always new options. Three years ago Twitter was not really a factor. I remember playing with it during the 2006 SXSW and all I came up with was, "Why do I want to know where you are going for coffee at 2am on a Saturday night." So I abandoned my Twitter account and Twitter all together until March of 2008. Now Twitter is a force. Not the major force, but definitely player in any social media strategy. And Friendfeed, my favorite aggregation tool actually lost traffic in June 2009.

Picture 53

And while Twitter's phenomenal growth is entertaining to report on and write about, the granddaddy of them all is Facebook. So if you're gonna simplify, perhaps this is your STACK.

Picture 54

The numbers are running in favor of Facebook to become an ever-more dominate force in social media. Here's a tidbit from TechCrunch:  Facebook Is Now the Fourth Largest Site In The World.

@jmacofearth
permalink: http://bit.ly/social-stack

Related Posts:

The PPT presentation above is available for download from Slideshare.net

Tags: , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , ,


Jun 28 2009

FriendFeed, Delicious, Feedburner: Hunting for the "links for date" Preference

Category: lifestreaming, toolsjmacofearth @ 6:23 am

Picture 8

I have been on a hunt to find the app that is posting this summary "links for" Tweet for a week.

My first two targets were FriendFeed (my primary aggregation service) and Delicious (where the social bookmarks begin and end for me) but was unable to find any information about this Feature (fail) on either site.

Today I was looking at the performance of my Feedburner RSS feeds and I finally found this screen:

Picture 7

So something called Link Splicer on FeedBurner was injecting this little pest into my tweetstream. I know, I know, I turned it ON in the first place. But immediately could not figure out where or how I had set the preference until today.

Thankfully, I have deactivated Link Splicer.

@jmacofearth
permalink: http://bit.ly/tweet-splice

Tags: , , , , , , , , , ,


Next Page »


WCG - this healthcare team rocks the web

socialmedianinja-x180

social media innovation group

future posts

Are you Wikipedia savvy? A bit about the process, trolls and the "spirit of the project" and "good faith" efforts.
The Agile Stack: How to Speed-the-Web. What's in your social media toolbox?
"We Googled You" : What You'd Better Know About Your SERP on Google

Add to Technorati Favorites

Austin Interactive Media Association

meterthis! momentum logo

Alltop for Social Media

Grader score for uber.la!

The NEW Twindle

trillion-joker-badge

Blogged Blog Directory