Quantcast


Mar 03 2010

Why Google BUZZ Does NOT Matter: 3 Reasons to "Turn Off Buzz."

Category: lifestreaming, social media, speed the web, tech opinion, tech reviews, toolsjmacofearth @ 10:57 am

image: google buzz inside G-Mail - what's the value?

[3-4-10: It's been 20 days since I looked in my Google Buzz folder. Am I missing something? What? Now, if you want to jump on a WAVE with me, I'm all fingers and toes.]

How Even the Mighty Google Fails Sometimes. Maybe you can call me Anti-Buzz, or Buzz-Kill, but I am not excited about Buzz at all. Here's why:

Can you tell me one thing Buzz does BETTER than the other tools available? We talked about it at a company dinner last night (and these are smart social media-y kinda folks) and nobody could say why BUZZ was even interesting. Three points of interest might be:

1. Google-always-does-killer-apps? Nah. 2. Plugs into G-mail? Not that interesting. 3. Has a fantastic mobile app? Er… No. I can't wait until the first person asks me, "Did you get my Buzz?" I savor the moment.

So what if these are the struggling throws of a fumbling giant? Google! So strong, so innovative, launching all these pet projects that have no integration and no coherence with one another. How does WAVE tie to Buzz. How does Orkut or Jaiku or Google Profile for that matter, have ANY connection or benefit from a BUZZ link?

Okay, so if I sound frustrated, it's because I am. Buzz is a big miss! We are spending valuable resources and time trying to figure out why we need another tool that really doesn't do much beyond the tools we have.

At Dell, the story goes, when Michael Dell looked at the prototypes of Dell's 2008 entry into the MP3 player market, he asked, "What does it do that the iPod doesn't?"

I think the Google developers need to ask themselves the same question. "How does this tool/project/platform/service provide something that does not exist? Or at the very least, "How does this product kick butt over the other products available?"

When the answer comes up "I dunno!" Perhaps even mighty Google should pause and ask, "Is this product going to move the Google Brand, the Google Application Suite, forward?"

As the Goo-Giant lumbers forward, even BING is getting some love because we kinda want Microsoft to return to some sense of sanity. I mean many of us depend on Windows products to make a living.

Score some HUGE wins for Google: Voice, Sync, Apps, Chrome (browser), Android.

Score some BONERS for Google: WAVE, Buzz, Orkut.

And a few TBD for Google: Caffeine, Real-time search integration, Twitter indexing.

So I'd like to see Google did what Apple did for their Snow Leopard update to OS X. No new features only FASTER, MORE STABLE, and REFINEMENTS. Imagine.

Here's how my G-mail tab looks now that I've killed Buzz.

Screen shot 2010 02 11 at 6.30.29 PM Why Google BUZZ Does NOT Matter: 3 Reasons to Turn Off Buzz.

And here's the link I clicked to kill it: "turn off buzz" will be a trending topic more than "turn on buzz" as shown below.

Screen shot 2010 02 11 at 6.31.36 PM Why Google BUZZ Does NOT Matter: 3 Reasons to Turn Off Buzz.

@jmacofearth
permalink: http://bit.ly/why-buzz

Product Review News: Looks into Buzz for a Clue

Yesterday's Anti-Buzz Rant from Uber.la: What's the BUZZ Tell Me What's Happening with Facebook vs Google Buzz?

Update and push back from some: Why Google Buzz is Brilliant by Christopher S. Penn.

google buzz with chris brogan and christopher s penn

And my response:

Okay, I'll be happy to disagree with this one Chris. It's not that I don't like where you are going with your post here, but I think the process of "pruning back hard" is important on Facebook and Twitter and not just a part of adding yourself (or not adding yourself) to the buzz. You are spot on about the clatter and churn washing up within social networks. Even LinkedIN is getting kind of spammy, don't you think? So what are we to do? Join the Buzz-wagon?

I think what we must do, on whatever networks we happen to be fond of, is cut back against the spammers. Box off the trolls. Delete the snipers. Use apps like Disqus to silence the cr*p that makes it across all of our blogs today as "conversation."

There are awesome tools to help you cull your spammers on Twitter. I am sure there will be similar apps for Facebook and perhaps Buzz. But the problem is not solved by adding a new app, the problem is solved by behaving in a new way. By building better habits, purging our "followers" and not just the ones we follow we get more REAL with the social part of the networking.

I love seeing the picture above of you guys. See Brogan is a workin Geek like the rest of us. Sometimes his writing is so damn good, and his approach is so damn real, I forget he's just sittin at the table trying to do better like the rest of us. Rock On CB! And Rock on CSP!

Tags: , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , ,


Feb 07 2010

Browser Love: ArsTechnica Reveals Their "worldwide" Stats & Uber.la Compares

Category: how do i?, social media, speed the web, tech opinion, toolsjmacofearth @ 8:03 am

If you hate IE raise your hand.

If you didn't raise your hand you may not understand the following post. That's okay, I'll try to be clear.

ONE: Microsoft IE (all versions) is the WORST browser on the market.
TWO: Problems in IE 6, might appear different than problems in IE 7, or IE 8, or god forbid, IE 5 which still shows some tenacity in my traffic on uber.la, a good portion coming from outside the US. (ArsTechnica has a nice collection of how the world is trying to put IE 6 to pasture.)
THREE: Microsoft Killed Netscape Navigator. And then ran uncontested until Firefox and Safari came along. Google's Chrome is still pretty new to the browser market. I have to say I like what Google is doing better than FF or Safari.
FOUR: If you develop websites, or do ANY email marketing, the biggest problem you have, all day and every day is IE. All versions have big problems. If Microsoft decides to fix change something in IE 8 they inevitably break a fix that was created to get IE 7 or IE6 to behave. Quite frankly, Microsoft doesn't give a damn. And these statistics aren't going to change that. But here they are from ArtsTechnica and then my little neck of the woods.

arstechnica reports their worldwide browser share
ArsTechnica: IE8 and Chrome have most momentum in browser wars

But I'm not exactly "worldwide" and my hunch is that neither are you. Let me explain and then show you some browser and OS stats of my own.

Worldwide means every single computer connected to the net. And of those computers a vast majority of those are running Windows. Funny thing is a ton of them are running Windows XP or earlier systems.

So of all these computers running Windows there is a huge chance that the user has not ever changed the default internet settings. And each of these settings on a "worldwide" scale affect the balance of browser and OS usage "worldwide" like this:

Setting one: browser = IE.
Setting two: homepage = MSN.
Setting three: OS = Windows.

So it's not to hard to see how Windows still claims the dominant OS and IE the dominant browser. But that's kind of like us in the US declaring English as the dominate language because HTML uses English expressions. There are a few languages that are bigger than English when you go to "worldwide" as your playing field.

So one of the obvious differences here on uber.la is our audience is skewed towards techie and English speaking folks. And most people use FF. IE is a distant second with 25% of the market. That's a pretty big jump down from the 63% on ArsTechnica's worldwide stats. And Chrome and Safari had a pretty healthy percentage as well. Obviously these are not people who have left their settings on the default IE settings.

What else can we see from our little microscope?

stats: browser share of market - Jan 5 to Feb 5 2010

And when you look at browser and OS combos the picture is even clearer.

Stats: OS market share - Jan 5 to Feb 5 2010

63% of our visitors are on Windows.
35% of our visitors are on Macintosh.
2% of our visitors are on Linux.

*I have filtered my Mac/FF and Mac/Chrome visits out of the reporting. And since the uber.la content is slanted towards techie, creative, literate readers you can see our audience is much more Mac savvy than the general population. And about 100 X more Mac than the worldwide internet population.

I write a lot about Apple, iPad, iPhone and other things OS X related so it is easy to imagine why my stats have such a higher average of Macs.

And finally, I'm a HUGE mobile advocate, but on my own site it is easy to see why mobile is not a primary strategy of mine. I do have a mobile-enabled WordPress extension that allows the phones to see my content properly. But still it makes up a tiny fraction of my traffic.

It has been the year of mobile for the last three years in a row. And many will declare this the "year of mobile" as well. And I believe for the most part mobile connections are for shopping (amazon), gaming, search (google),  travel directions (google maps, gps-enhanced apps) and messaging. (Twitter, Facebook etc.) I suspect with the iPad we will see a new surge in mobile browsing and mobile reading. But for longform content, and reading multipage articles the tiny screen is a less than optimal user experience. The busy blog format on Uber.la would drive most people crazy on a phone without the mobile template system I use.

All that said, we don't have much mobile traffic.  We don't really have a reason to be pushing our stream on to mobile, but here is how the mobile platform breaks out here on uber.la:

Screen shot 2010 02 06 at 12.35.26 PM Browser Love: ArsTechnica Reveals Their worldwide Stats & Uber.la Compares

So you have to look at the data and make some actionable decisions and then make changes. For example, I saw that I had a few mobile readers and I installed a mobile-template that auto detects for mobile OS connections and pushes them to a mobile-ready page.

As I said to a friend last week, "The tools are great, but it's the human interpretation of the data that determine success."  Data points and visual displays of analytics data are interesting, but we've got to make sure we can make solid decisions based on the data.

@jmacofearth
permalink: http://bit.ly/browser-love

ArsTechnica: Google Tries to Speed the Demise of IE6

Another nice ArsTechnical worldwide browser stat: from November 2009

stats: worldwide browser usage including version

Tags: , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , ,


Jul 08 2009

What's the Deal with Google Chrome OS, Google Chrome, GWave, Gmail, Google Apps

Category: social mediajmacofearth @ 4:27 pm

Is the OS heading into the Clouds?

Here's a picture of what's coming:

  1. You're new computer is going to come with some software system to get the processor, battery, ram and hard drive to all talk to one another and power up together to become your "computer".
  2. You are going to launch a "browser" or "os" depending on who you are listening to.
  3. Within that App/Browser/System you will access all of your documents, your email system and the applications you need to use to deal with the various document types.
  4. Most file types (.DOC, .XLS, .TXT, .PPT) will be handled without any brand named applications. You won't need WORD if the .DOC files is readable and editable in your "browser."
  5. Your task-based systems (EMAIL, TWITTER, CONFERENCE CALLS, MEETING MGMT) will all be handled by the "browser."

What is left?

High-end apps like Photoshop or iMovie will sill require some direct access to your system, outside the browser. And high-end editing and financial functions will be handled within the Branded apps of WORD, EXCEL and CUSTOM LABELED APPS like Quickbooks or Great Plains.

But for the masses, and this is who we are really talking about when we talk about the "consumer," will not care what OS they have, nor will it make any difference for 90% of what they are doing: which is browsing the web, watching YouTube, doing Facebook and sending emails and IM/Tweets. Seriously, for that, you could use a 2-3 year-old pc running anything plus a modern browser.

So as Google lines up it's ducks (Browser, OS, eMail, Apps and Social Media management system {WAVE}) the folks in Redmond are trying to cook up an OS that anybody believes in (WIN7), a search engine that can even come to the same party as Google (Bing) and new versions of their vaunted Office applications that will be living closer and closer to the cloud.

It's going to be an amazing year to watch. Let's just hope the economy picks back up so these great innovations have the financial fuel to move forward with gusto.

I'm happy on my Mac OS (no Chrome browser available yet) and FireFox. And I have to use Office Suite to communicate with my peers. And I love Adobe's CS4. But I can tell you, I will not buy a Windows-enabled PC at anytime if the near future, unless you count Virtualized versions that run on a Mac.

@jmacofearth
permalink: http://bit.ly/google-clouds

Some cloud-related posts:

Tags: , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , ,


Jan 12 2009

The View – A Deeper Exploration (seeking a social media killer app)

Category: speed the web, tech opinion, trust & reputationjmacofearth @ 1:01 am

"The evolution of social media depends on the evolution of the browsing experience."

Open Source Collaboration is about Virtual Teams using web tools to manage and communicate asynchronously while still maintaining priorities and quality of communication. The first step on any new project (open or closed) is to  define the goal.

This post is only part of the challenge, but the goal of FFoFF has morphed into a process I refer to as The Cloud >> The View >> The App. And that process or workflow is the basis for a conversation I am intending to have with other simliar minded seekers. The goal is not to create the next killer app, or uber browser, the goal is to define what that evolved web experience might look like. And then, using free plugins, apps and browsers (0riginally FFoFF or FriendFeed on FireFox) to get as close to the goal as possible.

Through this discussion [preferably not a monologue] the intention is to articulate the needs and challenged of the next generation web experience. The evolution of social media depends on the evolution of the browsing experience. Things like secure transactions anywhere, on-the-fly translated content, consolidated profile management (across all of your networked sites) and public and private personas are all part of the puzzle that will drive the next generation of social media connections and networks.

THE VIEW
(an invitation to dialogue and collaborate to build the requirements and demo of the UBER UI for the "social web.")

  1. The project
  2. The tools
  3. The rationale
  4. The solutions
  5. The view
  6. The team
  7. The genesis

1. The project

Defining the Evolved Browser or Uber App for Social Media

2. The tools

  • FireFox 3 is the development platform and interface.
  • The tools are widgets, social media sites, online apps, clouds of data and on and on.
  • And FriendFeed is my current choice for uber aggregator of social content.

3. Rationale

  • I believe we can iterate an Uber Interface (a VIEW) that will have amazing flexibility and require a ZERO DOLLAR dev budget.
  • My Firefox bookmark bar is already a sort of streamlined UI. It is not good enough, and constantly changing and evolving. But it is FREE.

4. The Solution – Usage models for the solution.

  • The uber social master VIEW
  • BrainTraining and Teaching VIEW
  • The newbie VIEW

5. The VIEW

A view is a design and grouping of FFoFF elements. A view is an iteration. A view is a proof and hypothesis.

6. The team

John McElhenney

7. The genesis

Note:
I am searching for that initial FFoFF person and will post the link here poste haste. And if it's you, please jump in and put yourself on the TEAM. Also please see Socialwiki and Wikisocial for an evolution of this process to an open source directory project.

[Initial wiki page created 7-15-08]

@jmacofearth
permalink: http://bit.ly/theview-exploded

Related posts:

Tags: , , , , , ,


Sep 02 2008

Google Chrome Shares No Love – Am I Scared, Nah!

Category: tech opinion, tech reviewsjmacofearth @ 1:01 am

The GOOGLE CHROME Launch was announced via an online comic book. But don't imagine that they are just fooling around in the browser space. Let's hope they are not kicking off an new era of "browser wars."

Okay, so what if the most powerful force on the web today entered the free browser market? And what if they controlled over 50% of the ad revenue generated on the web? And then what if they started tweaking code for "their" browser rather than everyone's browser?

Soon we might began noticing that things are looking just a bit different in FF and IE. And the pages seemed to load at about the same speed when Chrome launched definitely seem faster in Chrome. And then those cool embedded ads and adwords and blogs and widgets that are all part of the Chrome experience, and a couple of them are introduced as "chrome exclusive."

Fine call me paranoid. Don't call me a huge MS fan or anything, but this is the next step in shipping a Google OS.

It is fine to proclaim to do no evil. But will Google behave within the Open Source Community as a partner and not an enemy?

Once FF was the new kid on the block, and v3 looks pretty smooth. But are you serious, we now have to test for THREE browser formats again? Oh my. Maybe IE 8 will fix some of the things IE 7 broke. Who knows, maybe the Google OS will be good for computing on all processor platforms.

Now if Google buys Adobe, all bets are off on the evil thing.

TechCrunch does the Google Chrome cartoon as "We Really Hate Microsoft."

@jmacofearth
permalink:

Tags: , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , ,


Next Page »


WCG - this healthcare team rocks the web

socialmedianinja-x180

social media innovation group

future posts

The Lifetime Value of a "Connection" - Business is One Thing, Deep Friendship Another Thing Entirely
Dell's Amazing Twitter Success: Were We Pawned Into An Illusion of the Commercial Potential of Twitter?
"We Googled You" : What You'd Better Know About Your SERP on Google

Add to Technorati Favorites

Austin Interactive Media Association

meterthis! momentum logo

Alltop for Social Media

Grader score for uber.la!

The NEW Twindle

trillion-joker-badge

Blogged Blog Directory