I was asked by a friend who is still at Dell, “So how would you fix Dell.com, Mr. Mac?” This post was my FIRST response. Turns out they wanted to know more about my idea. My friend was adamant that I not criticize without offering a solution. “This is not a complete solution and you know it. You worked here.”
Back in the day, I used to propose these types of simplifications to Dell while I was employed by them. They didn’t listen. In fact, the VP in charge of this “cow path” structure alerted my manager when I requested a coffee with him. Here is Manish Mehta’s post from July 7, 2021 on the, then-new, Direct-to-Dell blog. Un-concreting the Cow Path
So Dell no longer solicits my advice. But I think I know a little bit about Dell and branding and online sales. And waaaaaay back in the day, I even suggested Dell get into the e-commerce space before anyone knew what e-commerce was. We were building the initial unified structure for dell.com. So you could say I’ve been working on Dell.com my entire career, with varying degrees of success. They didn’t listen at that point either. Even so, a year later Dell.com was the largest e-commerce website in the world. Oh well, I can say, “I was there.” And that’s about it.
Jump cut to 2012. I have written a few pieces critical of Dell.com architecture in the past. Most recently I broke down Dell’s dizzying array of computer “lines” or “brands” and how there are more than 35 different models of Dell laptops to choose from. I think that the number of options is overwhelming to visitors of Dell.com. And then add the “cow path” pricing and deal searching and you could easily spend all day trying to find the best deal and the computer that you want on Dell.com. This “might” have something to do with why Apple’s market share grew 10% in Q4 2011, while every other major manufacturer’s share dropped.
So here is my idea to simplify Dell.com and finally get to a UNIFIED PRICING structure on Dell.com. It is fine to put a 2nd BUSINESS or CONTRACT-specific site up for all the vertical markets that Dell needs to cater to. But let the buyer choose what they want then give them the BEST PRICE. No matter what “path” they go down, give the end consumer the SAME PRICE. Today it’s like used car shopping. You go down one “path” get a price for an Inspiron. Go down another path get a price for a similar Vostro. And finally, go down a third path and get a price on a Latitude. And that’s if you don’t want to compare all the options. You can’t get the same configuration or price twice in thirty minutes.
Now, there will be many complaints about my concept of eliminating the cow path. And nothing will happen on Dell.com. And I will go on trying to figure out how so many really smart people continue to make such huge mistakes. The answer is much simpler than the hierarchy of power that exists in Dell’s matrix organizational structure. And a proposal like this is heretical. I would be, and was, labeled a “loose cannon” and my Dell career trajectory would be redirected towards the exit.
My sincerest hope for Dell’s continued success does not prevent me from speaking out when I see something that does not make sense. I remember one morning when I saw Dell’s NEW BRAND the “Studio.” I asked the Director over me, “Can you please explain to me what the Studio has that Inspiron does not, and why are we adding yet ANOTHER brand to the consumer market?” She never answered me. The Studio line is now gone. Good move Dell. You’ve only got 4 more product lines to go.
Disclaimer: I was not paid, am not paid, in any way for my opinions or advice on Dell.com. I worked at Dell from 2007 to 2009 and I loved most of that time. I have been working “for” Dell in an agency capacity since 1994.
I may have even been one of the architects of Dell.com 1.0, long before Mr. Mehta arrived. Still, he didn’t want to hear my ideas, or hear from someone so low in the organization. I was slapped back into my swim lane. I just wanted to have a conversation with the guy. He gave me my first sharp elbow at Dell. I learned that elbows weren’t the only things that were sharp at Dell.
John McElhenney — let’s connect online
Facebook & LinkedIn & The Whole Parent
Please check out a few of my books on AMAZON.
Especially this one, about living a creative life of intention and joy.